I was raised as a JW. Was an active part of the congregation till about 2010. And boy do I have opinions about it.
There were so many rules to follow. It was very strict but depending on each families individual beliefs, it could be even more strict. (I knew a family who wouldn't let their kids watch the movie All Dogs Go To Heaven because it had to do with spirits) One common rule was not to have friends in school because they were "worldly" and bad associations. Anyone not in the kingdom hall was a bad association. We were warned not do do extra curricular things so as to not be "unevenly yolked with the world.
I was taught from a young age to care what everyone thought. Often being told "how would that make Jehovah look?" "What would the elders think?" I still have problems to this day caring too much about what everyone else thinks.
I got in trouble for the dumbest things. I was taken to "the little room" to talk to the elders when I was a teen because I had a friend in high school who was a boy. I felt like I was being interrogated. It wasn't anything more than a literal friend in school. That interaction with the elders honestly left me traumatized.
As a young adult I got in trouble again. A group of us got together to go bowling. In this group was my boyfriend at the time (who later became my first husband). Since a large group got together we all met up at my boyfriends house where he and another friend lived and decided to leave our cars there and carpool in fewer cars. I got scolded that it looked bad that I left my car at my boyfriends house and that it could be interpreted as me being alone with him in his apartment. Yeah. I still cant believe that happened.
I followed all the rules the church had for me. It was a full time job. I attended 5 meetings a week. Prepared ahead of time for each of the meetings. Was part of the theocratic ministry school where we had to frequently present skits of us having a bible study. I did this all while being in school with all my assignments and even while working full time.
I eventually got married just the way the church wanted. Married the brother I was dating. He was in good standing and came highly recommended.(Let's not forget the fact that not one person warned me about his father who they all knew. He was disfellowshipped many times, had a history of violence, been in and out of prison and even raped a 80 yr old woman. No one thought to even tell me what was attached to my husband.. good looking out) We had a short engagement just as the congregation suggested. After we got married we both pioneered which meant we had to put a ton of hours in for service. I did this while working full time. I would start early morning service before work, I even witnessed during my lunch at again after work. I did 10 hour weekends just to be able to put my time in. I was exhausted but I did it because its what was expected and I wanted to be accepted. I was never truly happy. Because no matter what I did it was still never enough for the congregation. Eventually all the long hours and stress took a toll. I had to stop pioneering. I was approached and told that even though I had contributed to the kingdom hall with my service for nearly a year I would have to be uninvited from the upcoming pioneer picnic because I wouldn't be a pioneer at the time it was being held. And don't forget that the elders had to make an announcement on stage before the entire congregation that I was no longer a pioneer. Nothing like a little public shame and humiliation. Although I did nothing wrong and it wasn't technically scolding... its just public announcement of ones position in the congregation. And this was a step down.
Fast forward to my first husband leaving me while pregnant and stealing our entire savings from me and leaving me desolate... among other things. I desperately wanted some sort of justice after he did what he did. The congregation wasn't giving it to me. He was still a ministerial servant and still had not had any sort of announcement that he was not in good standing. I had to blackmail him to get that sort of justice. I told him I would not sign the divorce papers until he spoke to the elders. He eventually did and he was disfellowshipped. But that would not have happened if it wasn't for my own efforts.
Fast forward to January 2012. My sister was going to get married to her baby daddy. Something that had been in the works since she became a teen mom. It was an abomination in the church that a teen got pregnant out of wedlock. Somehow she wasn't disfellowshipped. I honestly think it was due to my moms fragile mental health. With so many attempted suicides I think they knew would attempt again. So my sister got a slap on the wrist. By the time the wedding was planned her son would be around 18 months old. She was pressured the whole time by the church to get married and she finally started the planning. I want to say about a week before the wedding the congregation reached out to my parents and told them that everyone from the church who attended my sisters wedding would get reprimanded because she was marring a non believer. This was because despite attending meetings his whole life her soon to be husband was never baptized. So in order to not call off the entire wedding my sister and her baby daddy had to go to a ghetto hole in the wall wedding chapel and legally get married before her actual wedding. I saw what that did to my sister. What should have been a happy time was not. She was so sad to be in this disgusting place getting married. She even wore black to this legal wedding. It was absolutely horrible. We both cried at how awful this was. It was at this moment that the straw broke the camels back and I saw that this was not for me anymore.
I eventually stopped attending church. I still had my own relationship with god as I still do today. I have found such peace and joy in how that relationship is today. It finally feels right. I still believe many of the same beliefs as what I was taught growing up. But clearly I don't follow all the rules they do. Thus why I no longer call myself a JW. Through the years I have had family both immediate and distant encourage me to come back to the congregation. Saying things like Jehovah doesn't forget his lost sheep. I AM NOT LOST. These same people hold my idiot brother in high esteem simply for the fact that he is an elder in his congregation despite all the shit he has done and continues to do.
Recently when my dad passed and we were planning the memorial my mom asked me to write a eulogy for his service from us kids. In the week leading up to the memorial I was under such stress and emotional distress. There was a going back and forth about if I would be allowed to speak during the service. If it would be played as a recording. If it would be during the service or after. First, it was brought to my moms attention that I was not in "exemplary standing" in the kingdom hall. And that apparently has weight as to if I am worthy or not enough to say my last words after my dads death. FUCK YOU. Then was the question if it would even be appropriate for me to stand at the podium and address the congregation because I am a woman and women dont have those rights in the hall. So then the idea of me standing off to the side or even sitting in the audience with a mic was brought up. The elders in my moms congregation told her it was up to her and her discretion. But my cousin who is an elder was asked by my mother to do the talk and he was the one who really fought tooth and nail to not have me do it. At first he said we would have the service and then the prayer and when it was done for me to include it. Not having it part of the actual service is insane and insulting. We had to fight to have it during the service BEFORE any closing prayer and song. And the compromise that he agreed to was playing a recording I made after his talk and before the end of the service. During this back and forth conversation with him and my mom she said she hated the judgment from the hall about my standing in order to be part of my dads service, this will be relevant later. At the end of the day it worked out because I probably wouldn't have been able to get through it if I had tried to read it in person.
More recently. After my dad's passing my mom has been trying to figure out her finances and after many calls it seems she cannot afford to stay in her home. I scheduled a phone call with she and I and a financial advisor friend of hers from her hall. During the call we were discussing housing options and my mom was crying and said something along the lines of "I serve god and I cannot see myself living with family who isn't serving god." She meant me. In the years my dad was in hospice my mom and I talked many times about what the plan will be once pop dies. No plans were ever solidified, and they still aren't, but she made it clear that I was the only option. So to hear this was just so disgusting to hear especially on the heels of her telling the brothers she hated the judgements against me during the planning of pops service. And yet here she is doing the same thing. And by the end of the conversation she once again said I was the only one she felt comfortable with. I honestly feel sick to my stomach about it. I'll never be good enough despite being the only one of her children that doesn't want her money. She trusted me with that so much that she made me her POA and I have access to all her funds. I have never taken advantage of her. I have been the only child of hers to always look out for her. I help her pay her bills, get her medications. Contact her regularly to make sure she's ok. In the recent fires in Eaton Canyon I offered all the time to evacuate her. Driving through not one but two active burning fires to get to her. I made sure my kids had a relationship with her and my dad. But no... its still not worth anything because I chose to separate myself from a church that brought me no happiness. I followed their rules to not only continue being judged just to be told its still not good enough, but also to have a horrendous first marriage where everything in my life went to shit.
All that to say: I will never attend another meeting of JW again. I will never be an active member according to their standards. I will continue to have a relationship with Jehovah in the way that feels the most authentic and joyful for me. I continue to confide in him in the way I need. My relationship with god is between me and him and no one else. I am the happiest I have ever been in my life. I hope one day you can be happy for me too. Please stop telling me to come back to meetings. It is never going to happen. Take a real lesson out of the bible about not judging. I will never tell you to not serve god the way you want. I will never tell you I don't agree with what you are doing. I will never discourage you from doing what you want. Why don't you extend that same courtesy to me. That's the true christian thing to do. Because honestly was I feel is summed up into this: THERE IS NO HATE LIKE CHRISTIAN LOVE.

